Post by slapnut19 on May 5, 2020 6:45:11 GMT -6
(Facepalm)
You do realize that Rodgers playoff win/loss ratio is better than Mannings too, right?
Lmfao so actual production doesnt matter, it's all about wins and losses, but Peyton has a lesser win/loss ratio in the playoffs than Rodgers..... do you see the issue here? The very thing you are appealing to that makes Peyton > Rodgers, Rodgers is STILL better at lmao. Your excuse about Peyton having to play the Cheatriots obviously doesnt make up for the fact that he plays WAY worse in the playoffs than Rodgers and also has a lesser playoff win/loss ratio.
Not really fair to credit Peyton with an additional ring considering (not only did he have nothing to do with actually winning it), he didnt get that ring until he was older than Rodgers is now. So we have to give Rodgers the same amount of time.
Even relative to the era they played in, noone else on your list compares to Rodgers statistically, Marino would be the closest but you didnt mention him.
4 super bowl appearances vs 1. Case closed. The fact that manning got to 2 and won another super bowl late in his career isn't helping your argument
... and neither is this Chris guy.